Are payday loans always a bad idea? Here's the good,bad & ugly.

By Natasha Culzac

You’ve got over two weeks until payday. All’s dandy except, your card has just been declined in Tesco.

You realise you’re totally out of money and have nobody to borrow from or perhaps there is, but god knows you won’t let them know that you’re skint. Do you get out a payday loan until the end of the month?  Controversial payday loans are never out of the news, it seems. For the unfamiliar, the set-up is that borrowers can take out fairly instant, fairly small, short-term loans with spectacularly high interest rates. You generally pay them back when you get your salary. So what’s all the fuss about?

The good

Emergency cash for the rent, a bill, or whatever life crisis there is - payday loan companies serve a purpose in that they can help you out of some sticky situations, fast. Getting the loan is pretty straightforward: you do an online application and can even get the money in your bank account the same day. It’s all perhaps a bit too easy!

You can borrow anything from £50 to around £2,000, even for those with poor credit history who would struggle to be approved elsewhere.  With some firms, if you pay your loan back early, you could even save money as you’ll only pay interest on the days you borrowed it. And if it turns out you need more dollar after taking out a loan, you may be able to top it up.

You don’t necessarily have to pay back the entire lump once payday swings around. For many payday firms, you can take out a loan and choose to pay it off over a few months or even a year...

The bad

… but the staggeringly high interest rates mean you could end up paying double the original amount you wanted to borrow. For example, says a £500 loan spread out over 10 months will cost a total of £1,000 by the time it’s paid off. That’s £500 in interest! 

Many loans, however, are only taken out for a couple of weeks or a month. Wonga has a representative example that says a £200 loan over 30 days will cost you £48 in interest, so you’d pay back a total of £248.

The interest rates are so high because of the risks involved. Someone needing short-term cash may be in difficult financial circumstances and they may not be able to pay it back. It’s not particularly helpful to look at the APR (Annual Percentage Rate) rates, which are so eye-watering, because APRs are worked out as if the loan was a year long. More information on the APRs of payday loans can be found here.

If you miss your repayment, not only could there be a fee (it depends on the lender), but you could have to pay additional interest on the outstanding balance for each day that you fail to pay it.

The ugly

Borrowers can be trapped in a vicious cycle of taking out further money to pay off a previous loan. Regular payday borrower Christopher Arnold told us: “I was once in the ‘spiral of doom’ for five months. Each month you just need to borrow more and it gets out of control.” 

Hey, even Google now considers payday loans a ‘dangerous product’ and have banned payday ads from the site!

Additionally, if you have multiple payday loans within 12 months, this can seriously negatively impact your credit score. Each payday loan is credit checked and the more of these checks you have on your file within a short space of time, the higher the eyebrows are raised.

Key Takeaway

Payday loans really should be the very last option for your emergency cash needs. They can help when all other avenues are closed, but you must ensure that you pay it back on time and don’t get sucked into a never-ending cycle of robbing Peter to pay Paul. Click here to find out what different types of loans are out there.

Comments (0)

Log in or register to add your comment
Not a giffgaff member? Register now

giffgaff gameplan

Copyright ©2019 giffgaff

The giffgaff compare service for credit cards and loans is provided by Runpath Regulated Services Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority – FRN 728244). giffgaff compare is a trading style of Runpath Regulated Services Limited. In relation to credit card and loan services Runpath Regulated Services Limited is acting as a credit broker, not a lender; The table shows a range of products from the market and this service does not consider your personal credit position. Terms and conditions apply. Finance subject to status. 18s and over.

Representative example for a loan of £4,000 for 24 months at an interest rate of 15.5% APR fixed. In this example the total amount payable (including interest and fees) would be £4633.57 and your monthly repayments would be £193.07.

giffgaff receives a fee for introducing personal loans to Retail Money Markets Ltd trading as Ratesetter.

giffgaff gameplan is a trading style of giffgaff Limited, we are a credit broker and not a lender and introduce loan applications to its selected provider of loans Retail Money Market Limited trading as Ratesetter. Terms and conditions apply. Finance subject to status. 18s and over. Credit is provided by Retail Money Market Limited trading as Ratesetter, 6th Floor, 55 Bishopsgate, London EC2N 3AS Ratesetter is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority – Firm Reference Number 633741

giffgaff Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, Firm Reference Number - 680957. Registered address – giffgaff Ltd, 260 Bath Road, Slough SL1 4DX. Company Number - 04196996.

Posts on this site reflect the opinion of the members posting only, and not necessarily giffgaff’s opinions or views. There’s a lot of information here that can help you, however, you must remember that we operate an open forum and sometimes messages that are posted are misleading, deceptive, or inaccurate. If you follow these tips, you do so at your own risk. Always do your research and check the terms.